Do Smartphone Bans Work?

It depends on the goal

As states and school districts explore and implement bans on smartphones at school, the question remains: Will these bans improve the student learning environment?

The answer: Maybe.

Overall, 68% of US adults responding to a 2024 Pew Research Center survey say they support a ban on middle and high school students using their phones during class. The biggest reasons these Americans gave for backing the move? Fewer distractions (98%), better social skills (91%), less cheating (85%), and reduced bullying (70%).

And, bans are in place in a number of areas of the country:

As of November 4, 2024, eight states — California, Florida, Indiana, Louisiana, Minnesota, Ohio, South Carolina, and Virginia — have passed policies that ban or restrict phone use in schools. These broadly take effect during the current school year. Twelve more states have introduced such legislation.

Anecdotal evidence suggests some improvement – students actually talking to each other during lunch, for example. Less instances of social media bullying.

Still, the research is uneven in terms of whether these bans will have a long-term, positive effect.

One analysis of studies that analyzed cell phone bans in schools across the globe found:

“Overall, the results indicated that the ban and no ban schools either did not differ significantly, or there were minimal differences, in terms of problematic use of mobile phones, academic engagement, school belonging, and bullying,” the authors reported.

person holding iphone showing social networks folder
Photo by Tracy Le Blanc on Pexels.com

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Kentucky Kids to Lawmakers: Fund Our Schools

The School With No Teachers

MORE TENNESSEE NEWS

SNAP Benefit Delays Hurt TN Families

A Plan to Expand Pre-K in TN

Coping with Phone Addiction in Kids

Not just a distraction at school, phones also impact mental health

Managing screens at school can be a challenge.

A new California law seeks to prohibit “addictive content” from being served to children during school hours via cell phone apps.

Of course, there are all sorts of problems with implementation and enforcement.

But, the passage of this law points to an uncomfortable reality: cell phone addiction is a “new normal.”

We expect kids to be addicted to their phones, and are now entering the phase of attempting to “manage” that addiction.

Last year, Gallup found that over half of U.S. teens ages 13-19 spend an average of 4.8 hours a day on social media. Female teens spend an average of 5.3 each day on social media compared to the 4.4 hours average of teen males. A Common Sense Media Study found that 97% of kids 11 through 17 years old use their phones at school. The most popular usage among teenagers is TikTok at 32%, YouTube at 26%, and gaming at 17%.

pexels-photo-987585.jpeg
Photo by freestocks.org on Pexels.com

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

School Vouchers on the Ballot

The Persistent Teacher Pay Penalty

MORE TENNESSEE NEWS

Democrats Propose Free School Meals for All Kids

Corporate Tax Revenue Takes a Tumble