Category Archives: School Funding

Posted on by

Tennessee Earns an “F” in Support of Public Schools

As Gov. Bill Lee’s 8 years in office come to an end, his legacy is clear: Support for public schools is near the bottom in the nation, while efforts to privatize get top billing.

While the most recent analysis of public school funding places Tennessee last in the nation, a report released this week by the Network for Public Education (NPE) gives the Volunteer State a grade of “F” for its support (lack of support?) for public schools.

In a press release, NPE says:

Only two states — Nebraska and Vermont — earned an A. Seventeen states received an F, failing to meet even 40% of the points allocated across NPE’s 39 standards. Florida ranked last, scoring 14 out of 102 possible points, with Arizona close behind. “The data confirm what we have long suspected: privatization and disinvestment go hand in hand,” said Carol Burris, Executive Director of NPE and the report’s author. “These are not states struggling with limited resources. They have made deliberate choices to abandon their public schools while directing billions in public dollars to private alternatives.”

Relative to Tennessee, the report notes:

Florida lost every possible point in our school funding category, ranking in the bottom decile for funding level, distribution, and effort, while also paying among the lowest teacher salaries in the country when adjusted for cost of living. Arizona, Idaho, North Carolina, and Tennessee each earned just two of sixteen possible funding points.

The 17 states that earned an F for their lack of support of public schools, students, and educators while embracing privatization were (lowest to highest) Florida, Arizona, North Carolina, Louisiana, Indiana, Oklahoma, Idaho, Arkansas, Alabama, Utah, Texas, Tennessee, Georgia, Ohio, Nevada, South Carolina, and Missouri.

About the report:

The report draws on original research in addition to research from other organizations — including the Education Law Center, the Learning Policy Institute, and EdChoice — to deliver a comprehensive assessment of public education and privatization across 39 distinct factors. These include teacher-to-student ratios, teacher satisfaction, school funding levels, and the degree to which laws governing vouchers, charter schools, and homeschools protect both taxpayers and students.

Gov. Bill Lee promoting school privatization

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Why Does Tennessee Lead the Nation in Teacher Loss?

Why the Nashville Super Bowl is a Loss for Tennessee Kids

Posted on by

Bill Lee Bets Big on Super Bowl, Punts TN Kids to the Sidelines

Gov. Bill Lee and his GOP legislative supermajority have made their priorities clear: Hundreds of millions for stadiums and Super Bowls, zero for kids.

Nashville will host the Super Bowl in 2030, an event that promises to bring far smaller economic returns than the NFL or Lee suggests, based on results from cities that have actually held the Super Bowl.

Still, the state put up $500 million just to build a domed stadium for billionaires who couldn’t afford to spend their own money, while kids in DCS custody sleep on office floors because the state lacks adequate facilities to house them.

Oh, and Tennessee is also now last in the nation – 51st – in funding for schools, needing nearly $2 billion to even reach the same level as Mississippi.

cardboard illustration of paper money and coins on blue background
Photo by Gabby K on Pexels.com

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

What Do We Really Learn from Standardized Testing?

Tennessee’s Dance with White Supremacy

Posted on by

Architect of Tennessee’s Education Decline Gets Seat on Memphis Schools Oversight Board

House Speaker Cameron Sexton appointed Dave Mansouri, President and CEO of the Statewide Collaborative on Reforming Education (SCORE), to a new board that will oversee Memphis schools.

Chalkbeat reports:

David Mansouri, president and chief executive at Tennessee SCORE, has been appointed to the new nine-person oversight board that will seize control of Memphis-Shelby County Schools in a state-led takeover.

House Speaker Cameron Sexton appointed Mansouri to the board on Tuesday, one of the speaker’s two appointees on the board. Sexton has not announced his final pick.

Mansouri will be the only member of the new board who is not a Shelby County resident after Sexton negotiated for the opportunity to appoint a non-resident when Republicans passed the takeover legislation earlier this spring.

Mansouri doesn’t live in Memphis and has zero ties to the district.

He is, however, the leader of the organization that has been driving Tennessee education policy for over a decade.

Bill Frist and the BEP

Since SCORE’s founding, it has had the ear of Tennessee’s two GOP Governors – Bill Haslam and Bill Lee.

In that time, Tennessee has sunk to the bottom in the nation in investment in schools.

The state now has a private school discount coupon program (school vouchers) costing taxpayers $300 million a year – transferring wealth from rural and working class Tennesseans to wealthy families already sending kids to private schools.

Our state’s teachers are among the lowest-paid in the nation – lagging behind several of our Southeastern neighbors.

It’s not clear what positive impact SCORE has had for schools or Tennessee communities – except that its executives are handsomely paid. Mansouri earned nearly $400,000 in 2024 according to SCORE’s IRS 990 form. That same year, the group took in $17 million – ostensibly to advance meaningful education reform in Tennessee.

Perhaps Mansouri will actually visit Memphis now that he’s part of the group overseeing the city’s schools – and spend some of his and SCORE’s money there.

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Tennessee’s White Supremacy Dance

Charter Schools vs. Taxpayers

Posted on by

TISA and Tennessee’s Race to the Bottom

Tennessee is last. In school funding. In the whole country.

LAST.

Behind all our Southern neighbors. All of them.

As Gov. Bill Lee prepares to leave office this year, that’s his legacy – changing the school funding formula, spending hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars on private school discount coupons, and leading our state to dead last in school funding in the whole United States.

A recent story about Tennessee school funding notes not only is the state dead last in the nation in school funding, but also, the state’s investment in schools has dropped by 10% since the 2023-24 school year.

School funding in the state is dead last in the nation – and lower in real dollars than it was in the first year of TISA – 10% lower.

Teacher pay in the state?

Also lower than our neighbors – and lower in real dollars (6.5% lower) than a decade ago.

Lee’s legacy is clear: Less investment in schools, lower pay for teachers. Instead, Lee is spending $300 million next year to expand his private school discount coupon scheme – taking money from the least able to pay (and least likely to have access to private schools) and funneling it to the already quite wealthy.

crop man getting dollars from wallet
Photo by Karolina Grabowska on Pexels.com

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

TN Teacher Morale Sinking

Arizona Vouchers: Fraud Magnets

Posted on by

Will Tennessee Change Its Definition of “Economically Disadvantaged” Students?

A word from the Nashville Public Education Foundation (NPEF) on how the meaning of words makes a difference for public school kids.

Earlier this year, Tennessee lawmakers introduced a bill that would change the state’s definition of students who are economically disadvantaged. The bill proposed adding TennCare (Medicaid) participation as a factor in determining which students are designated as “economically disadvantaged.” Tennessee’s definition of this demographic, which was changed in 2016, is one of the most restrictive in the country: it currently counts students whose families are actively enrolled in SNAP and TANF in addition to other categorical factors, such as students experiencing homelessness or part of the foster care system. A major reason this definition is considered so strict is due to the low income threshold for qualifying for SNAP compared to other states – Tennessee’s income limit is 130% of the federal poverty guidelines, while many other states have enacted policies that effectively increase this threshold, with some states up to 200% of the federal poverty guidelines.

Adding in TennCare enrollment data, as the bill proposed, would result in a state definition of “economically disadvantaged” that much more accurately captured the socioeconomic reality and lived experiences of students and families. The implications of this definition became prominent when the number of students considered economically disadvantaged became directly tied to public school funding with the passage of TISA in 2022.

Despite bipartisan support, the state did not allocate funding for the costs associated with the definition change if the bill had passed. However, the bill was amended to task the TISA review committee to study Tennessee’s definition of economically disadvantaged, analyze how the state’s definition compares to that of other states, assess the impact on public schools, and make recommendations by November 2027. While not a full realization of the original bill, the amended version, which passed nearly unanimously in the state House of Representatives and Senate, demonstrates positive forward momentum and a shared commitment to addressing this issue.

cityscape of nashville tennessee at dawn
Photo by Cesar G on Pexels.com

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Under Bill Lee, Tennessee Schools “Win” Race to the Bottom

Exclusionary Vouchers in Arkansas

Posted on by

Why Has School Spending in Tennessee Dropped by 10% Since 2023-24?

WSMV reports that Tennessee now ranks last in the nation in school funding:

Tennessee has now been ranked as the worst state in the nation for spending on public school students from kindergarten through 12th grade.

The finding is part of a new report from the National Education Association that tracks teacher pay, student spending and education investment across the U.S.

The report shows that public school spending per student has dropped nearly 10% from the 2023-2024 school year. In that year, Tennessee ranked 48th in the nation for student spending.

Tennessee State Democrats called the findings “an indictment of one-party Republican governance.”

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Arizona Gov. Rejects Trump’s Vouchers

Denouncing Trump’s Private School Discount Scheme

Posted on by

Are Tax Cuts and Vouchers Replacing Public School Funding in Tennessee?

WKRN notes that a new analysis says Tennessee ranks last in the nation in school funding:

The report places the Volunteer State 51st in per-pupil spending, behind every other state and the District of Columbia, prompting criticism from Democratic lawmakers who argue the numbers reflect years of underinvestment.

“It shows the state has prioritized big tax cuts and a private school program rather than dealing with the most important investment we make in the state’s future,” State Sen. Jeff Yarbro (D-Nashville) said.

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

The Utah Voucher Fight

A Voucher Warning from Arkansas

Posted on by

Lamar Laments Tennessee’s Low School Funding

Tennessee is last in the nation in school funding, a new report shows.

Senate Democratic Caucus Chair London Lamar blasted the GOP supermajority and Gov. Bill Lee over the consistent underfunding of the state’s schools:

“While Gov. Lee and Republicans were busy shoveling hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars into their private school voucher scam, they left nearly a million kids in Tennessee’s public schools with less funding per student than anywhere else in the nation. This isn’t an accident — it’s a choice. And Tennessee families are paying the price.”

bitcoins and u s dollar bills
Photo by David McBee on Pexels.com

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Indianapolis: Privatized

Arizona Gov Rejects Trump Scheme

Posted on by

The Impact of Vouchers on Nashville

Tennessee policymakers and Gov. Lee have decided that funding a separate, $300 million voucher school system is more important than investing in our state’s public schools.

That decision carries real costs, as this letter writer to the Tennessean points out:

The wonderful public school my precious granddaughters attend has been informed that they will lose $338,000 this year. In essence, to have the same services in 2026-2027, they will have to find donors and philanthropies to chip away at this hole in the next few months, or drastically reduce staffing. Already, current staff cover two or three job descriptions, double up on learning support and, at the same time, have produced better test scores and student retention. The system disincentivizes success.

Four months to raise $338,000 that won’t provide extras or undergird new efforts. It’ll be just enough to maintain. Metro and the State do not provide fundraising support. PTAs are keeping the doors open, and moms are popping their trunks in the pickup line to provide diapers, hygiene products and food for students whose government-supported benefits have been reduced or stopped altogether.

cityscape of nashville tennessee at dawn
Photo by Cesar G on Pexels.com

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

The Painful Reality of “School Choice” in Arkansas

On Low Teacher Morale in Tennessee

Posted on by

We’ve Got the Plan, You’ve Got the Money

A tale out of Ohio highlights a frequent complaint in education: The unfunded mandate.

Lawmakers have the “best” idea – and if only districts would do it, everything would be great.

Funding? Districts don’t need money – just ideas. And mandates. Lots and lots of mandates.

This is the story of education a million times– some legislator gets a bright idea and declares “Let’s require schools to fix this” while waving vaguely in the direction of schools. And while this bright idea may require more resources and human-hours, that lawmaker will be confident that this whole new program can be implemented for free. Rick Hess has often said that you can force folks to do something, but you can’t force them to do it well. That is doubly true when you make zero effort to provide them with the resources needed to implement the program.

businessman man woman desk
Photo by Tima Miroshnichenko on Pexels.com

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Alarming Research on Kids and AI

Ending Public Schools