Vouchers Hurt Kids

Ohio data shows school voucher schemes lead to academic harms for students

Gov. Bill Lee’s top legislative priority since his election in 2018 has been a statewide school voucher scheme.

During a special legislative session in January, Lee’s dream was realized. While existing evidence suggested this plan would be both bad for taxpayers and harmful to kids, Lee persisted. Now, new data out of Ohio confirms that those warning of the harms of vouchers were onto something.

Let’s be clear: The data over more than a decade shows that vouchers are both very expensive and ineffective at improving academic achievement.

On all proficiency tests, students getting a voucher for one year or less overall are about 75% proficient. Three years later, they’re 54% proficient.

That’s a drop of nearly 1/3!

The Ohio numbers show that students did not improve in any subject – in fact, their scores declined!

Vouchers are bad.

They hurt kids.

And taxpayers will be on the hook for a program that doesn’t just “not work” it actually has negative impacts.

Bill Lee’s signature legislative achievement is a multi-billion dollar program that will hurt Tennessee kids.

Gov. Bill Lee promoting school privatization

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Elon Musks Takes Food from Schools and Food Banks

Bill Lee Also Doesn’t Want to Feed Kids

MORE TENNESSEE NEWS

Pastors Speak Out on Anti-Trans Bills

Pot for Potholes

Here’s How the Voucher Story Goes

It’s not a happy ending

A look at the voucher scheme in Florida offers a preview of where Tennessee is heading – and it’s not good.

An analyst in the state notes:

Peter Greene explores the Florida situation further, digging in with information from a professor from Florida State:

Cottle also wants to point out another factor. Florida used to run a huge budget surplus, but now it’s running a deficit. Cottle and others are trying to raise an alarm about math instruction and the need to improve math instruction, particularly by recruiting and retaining high-quality teachers. But the “still-growing budget for school choice vouchers is surely competing for money with ideas for initiatives to improve student learning, and the voucher budget is winning.”

In Tennessee, we should be alarmed:

Over the course of the next five years, as state funding is gobbled up by a privatization scheme and local taxes increase even as services offered remain the same or decrease, we can look back on this moment as the nail in the coffin of Tennessee public education.

Gov. Bill Lee won – and a generation of Tennessee students will lose as a result.

Gov. Bill Lee promoting school privatization

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

A 504 Lawsuit Explainer

The End of the Department of Education

MORE TENNESSEE NEWS

Bill Lee Won’t Request Summer Food Aid for Kids

Doctors Speak Out on Bill Lee’s Health Policy Disaster

Stop the Scam!

Rally against Bill Lee’s voucher scam TODAY

Supporters of public schools in Tennessee will hold a rally in Nashville today to express opposition to Gov. Bill Lee’s school voucher scam.

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Trump Pushes National School Voucher Scam

TN’s School Funding Failures

MORE TENNESSEE NEWS

A Warning on Healthcare

SNAP Leaves Families Starving in TN

Sen. Charlane Oliver Takes on Bill Lee’s Oligarchy

Should the gov’s rich friends profit at the expense of TN’s public schools?

State Sen. Charlane Oliver of Nashville pulled no punches in calling out Gov. Bill Lee’s school voucher scam.

Tennessee’s public education system is under siege by wealthy conservative oligarchs, including former Education Secretary Betsy DeVos, who are bankrolling Republican leaders to push school vouchers. Ultra-wealthy conservatives have made dismantling public education their mission, even descending upon Washington ready to disband the U.S. Department of Education.

Gov. Bill Lee promoting school privatization

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Arizona Gov. Pushes Back Against School Vouchers

TN’s School Funding Failures

MORE TENNESSEE NEWS

How SNAP Fails TN Families

Lawmakers Call Out Corporate Tax Loopholes

A Warning on Vouchers

They’re expensive and don’t work for kids

A national expert on education policy warned Tennessee lawmakers to proceed with caution when it comes to Gov. Bill Lee’s voucher scam.

Professor Josh Cowen of Michigan State University spoke at a forum hosted by Sen. Heidi Campbell and Rep. Caleb Hemmer. In his presentation, Cowen discussed his research into voucher programs across the country. Cowen said his findings suggest policymakers should be wary of school vouchers as a policy solution.

“These voucher schemes devastate student learning. The bigger and more recent the voucher system, the worse the results are for kids,” Cowen said. “Over the last decade, we see some of the largest test score drops for kids who transfer from public to private school using a voucher that we’ve seen on any question in the history of education research.”

Gov. Bill Lee promoting school privatization

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Kentucky Kids Fight for School Funding

Schools Without Teachers

MORE TENNESSEE NEWS

Bill Lee Offers Tax Loopholes for Billionaires

A Plan to Grow Pre-K in Tennessee

Oak Ridge and Voucher Opposition

Retired teacher speaks out against voucher scam

A retired teacher from Anderson County spoke to the League of Women Voters of Oak Ridge about the reasons she opposes Gov. Bill Lee’s school voucher scam.

Objections to the new bill that lawmakers must ponder this year were presented in a recent talk by Marsha Livingston, a retired teacher from Anderson County Schools.

Based on valid data comparing the educational outcomes of public and private school students in Tennessee the last two years and in other states with large rural populations, she said, student academic achievement based on test scores in public schools generally surpasses that of students in private schools supported by public money.

 She quoted Andy Spears, publisher of the Tennessee Education Report, who wrote, “With little data showing any significant positive gains, and new data suggesting possible harms, it’s difficult to understand why policymakers would adopt a voucher system in Tennessee.”

Gov. Bill Lee promoting school privatization

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Demanding Fully Funded Schools

Will the Trump Presidency Mean a National Voucher Scam?

MORE TENNESSEE NEWS

TN SNAP Leaves Families Starving

Aftyn Behn Wants to End TN’s Grocery Tax

Lee Calls Special Session to Pass Voucher Scam

Conservatives already speaking out against plan that would raise taxes while providing no real benefits

Today, Gov. Bill Lee called a special legislative session to focus on passage of his school voucher scam.

Today, Tennessee Governor Bill Lee announced that he will call for the Tennessee General Assembly to convene a special session on Monday, January 27, to pass the Education Freedom Act.

The session will also include a disaster relief package for areas impacted by Hurricane Helene.

Conservative groups are already speaking out against Lee’s voucher scam.

The Tennessee Conservative notes:

• With 10,000 scholarships initially available and expanding by 5,000 each year, the program’s long-term cost could strain Tennessee’s budget, leading to higher taxes for hardworking families.

• Public schools will retain their funding even when students leave, forcing taxpayers to fund both public schools and ESAs simultaneously. This double-dipping could bankrupt our state over time.

The math: TCN says the voucher scheme will cost $268 million in year one – and continue to be a drag on state and local budgets, likely resulting in tax increases:

Another conservative group, Tennessee Stands, says they oppose vouchers because:

Vouchers are wealth distribution. Vouchers are government funds that come with additional regulatory oversight. Vouchers are dangerous for home schools and private education.

Gov. Bill Lee promoting school privatization

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Kentucky Kids Call for Fair School Funding

The Real Story of School Funding in Tennessee

MORE TENNESSEE NEWS

SNAP Benefit Delays Leave TN Families Hungry

A Plan to Boost Recycling in Tennessee

Knox County School Board Rejects Voucher Push

Divided School Board votes against adding Lee’s voucher scam to legislative agenda

The Knox County School Board will not ask lawmakers to support Gov. Bill Lee’s school voucher push, despite an attempt by the Board’s GOP majority to adopt the issue.

The Knoxville News-Sentinel reports:

All Republicans except District 5 representative Lauren Morgan and District 9 representative Kristi Kristy voted Jan. 9 in favor of asking lawmakers to expand Tennessee’s private school voucher program. Kristy took a “pass” vote and Morgan voted “no.”

Morgan explained her “no” vote:

I don’t believe it’s in this board’s realm of duties to make vouchers a legislative priority as we don’t have control over what the legislator does. I think it’s our job here on this board to make Knox County Schools the best that they can possibly be and be the place where our students and our families want to get an education and choose to go to school.”

exterior of school building in daytime
Photo by Mary Taylor on Pexels.com

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

School Funding: Tennessee’s Failure

This One’s About Book Banning

MORE TENNESSEE NEWS

Lawmakers Release Corporate Tax Loophole Report

Should Pre-K be Expanded in TN?

Hemmer vs. Lee

Nashville Rep. exposes Bill Lee’s voucher lies

Nashville State Rep. Caleb Hemmer is calling out Gov. Lee’s voucher lies – exposing Lee as unwilling to meaningfully invest in public schools while pushing a private school voucher scam.

Once again, this new version is jam-packed with all kinds of seemingly nice things tacked on to try and distract people from the fact that this is all a scam designed to defund public education. Lee and his voucher scammers want you to pay attention to the long overdue teacher raises and the newly-dedicated funding source for school construction projects promised in the bill.

But let’s face it − if they were really serious about the proposals, they would have already done them. They wouldn’t have to tie them to a bait-and-switch scheme to designed to undermine public education and make out-of-state billionaire voucher backers happy.

The new money for teachers in Lee’s latest voucher proposal is a one-time bonus, not a long-term commitment to better pay.

While Lee claims to support investment in school infrastructure, schools are still waiting for funds while the Tennessee Titans have $500 million in state money for their new (smaller) stadium.

Gov. Bill Lee promoting school privatization

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Will Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear Run for President?

Washington State’s Investment in Teachers

MORE TENNESSEE NEWS

Behn, Campbell Challenge TN AG on Gender-Affirming Care

It’s Time to End TN’s Grocery Tax

Voucher Fraudsters

Arizona voucher program supports vibrant fraud industry

Arizona’s voucher program seems to be particularly fraud-prone.

Peter Greene notes the latest:

Today, Mayes announced yet another fraud case in which a couple has been charged with 60 counts of fraud, having put in applications for 50 students, 43 of whom do not actually exist. The couple– Johnny Lee Bowers and Ashley Meredith Hewitt– apparently did not even live in Arizona at the time. They grabbed around $100K, which they used for “personal living expenses,” so this was like their job, what they did for a living.

Here’s the deal: The voucher scheme in Arizona is busting the budget – and it is rife with fraud.

As TN lawmakers consider vouchers (again), they should look at the results in Arizona – lots of fraud, little ROI in terms of student outcomes.

bitcoins and u s dollar bills
Photo by David McBee on Pexels.com

MORE EDUCATION NEWS

Free School Lunch in Tennessee?

Red and Blue Voters Both Reject Vouchers

MORE TENNESSEE NEWS

Democrats Elect Legislative Leadership

Tax Relief for TN Families